Skip to Main Content

Evaluating Information Sources

Quick Guide

When you encounter any type of information source, ask yourself: 

  1. Authority - Who is the author? What is their point of view? 
  2. Purpose - Why was this source created? Who is the intended audience? 
  3. Publication & format - Where was it published? On what medium? 
  4. Relevance - Is this relevant for your research? What is the scope? 
  5. Date of publication - When was it written? Has it been updated? 
  6. Documentation - Did they cite their sources? Can you find those sources? 

In-Depth Guide

Authority 

  • Who is the author/publisher/creator/sponsor? 
  • What are their credentials? 
  • What else have they written? 
  • Can you find information about them online? 
  • Have you seen them cited in other relevant information sources? 
  • In which contexts and communities does the author have expertise? 
    • Does the author represent a particular worldview? 
    • Do they represent specific gender, racial, sexual, political, social and/or cultural orientation? 
    • Do they privilege some forms of authority over others? 
    • Do they have a formal role in a reputable institution (e.g. professor at Harvard, city council member)? 

Purpose

  • Why was this source created? To inform? Persuade? Entertain? Sell something? 
  • Does the author/creator make their purpose clear to the reader? 
  • Does the point of view appear objective? 
  • Are there political, ideological, cultural, institutional, or personal biases? 
  • Does it fill any other personal, professional, or societal needs? 
  • Who is the intended audience? 
    • Is it for scholars? 
    • Is it for a general audience? 

Publication & format 

  • Where was it published? 
  • Was it published in a scholarly publication, like an academic journal? 
    • Who was the publisher? A university press? 
    • Was there a peer-review process? 
    • Which discipline, or field of study, is the journal from? 
  • Does the publication have a particular editorial position? 
    • Is it considered a conservative or progressive outlet? 
    • Is the publication sponsored by any organizations or companies? Do those sponsors have particular biases? 
  • Were there any apparent barriers to publication? 
    • Was this self published? 
    • Were there any outside reviewers or editors? 
  • Where, geographically, was it originally published? In what language? 
  • In what medium was this published? 
    • Was it published in print? Online? Both? 
    • Is it a blog? YouTube video? Podcast? A TV episode? An article from a print magazine? 
      • What does the medium tell you about the intended audience? 
      • What does the medium tell you about the source's purpose? 

Relevance

  • How is it relevant to your research? 
    • Does it analyze the same primary sources you are researching? 
    • Does it cover the people/topic you're researching, but from another perspective or using other sources/data? 
    • Can you apply the author's theoretic or analytic framework to your own research? 
    • How many other sources have you examined before choosing this source? 
  • What is the scope of coverage? 
    • Is it a broad overview? Is it an in-depth analysis? 
    • Does the scope match your research needs? 
    • Is the geographic region or time period relevant for your research? 

Date of publication 

  • When was the original publication date? 
  • What version or edition of the source are you using? 
    • Are there differences in editions, such as a new introductions, footnotes, or chapters? 
    • If the publication is online, when was it last updated? 
  • What has changed in your field since the publication? Is this still accurate information? 
  • Are there any published reviews, responses or rebuttals?

Documentation

  • Did they cite their sources?
    • If not, do you have any other means to verify the reliability of their claims?
  • Who do they cite?
    • Is the author affiliated with any of the authors they're citing?
    • Are the cited authors part of a particular academic movement or school of thought?
  • Look closely at the quotations and paraphrases from other sources:
    • Did they appropriately represent the context of their cited sources?
    • Did they ignore any important elements from their cited sources?
    • Are they cherry-picking facts to support their own arguments?
    • Did they appropriately cite ideas that were not their own?
  • If they use links for their citations, are the links functional? 

Denison Libraries, 100 W College, Granville, Ohio 43023
Phone: 740-587-6235, email: reference@denison.edu
In order to view PDF documents, you will need to have the free Adobe Acrobat Reader software installed on your computer